| sort | Institution | Overall Score |
| 52 | Grace College and Seminary (IN) | 59 |
| 53 | Oakwood University (AL) | 59 |
| 54 | Kentucky State University (KY)* | 58 |
| 55 | Oklahoma Baptist University (OK) | 58 |
| 56 | John Brown University (AR) | 57 |
| 57 | Iowa Wesleyan College (IA) | 57 |
| 58 | Concordia University (MI) | 56 |
| 59 | Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Erie-Behrend College (PA)* | 56 |
| 60 | Embry Riddle Aeronautical University-Prescott (AZ) | 56 |
| 61 | University of Pittsburgh—Johnstown (PA)* | 56 |
| 62 | Lebanon Valley College (PA) | 56 |
| 63 | Eastern Nazarene College (MA) | 56 |
| 64 | Trinity Christian College (IL) | 56 |
| 65 | Blackburn College (IL) | 55 |
| 66 | Manchester College (IN) | 55 |
| 67 | St. Joseph's College New York (NY) | 55 |
| 68 | University of the Ozarks (AR) | 55 |
| 69 | Louisiana College (LA) | 55 |
| 70 | University of Montana—Western (MT)* | 54 |
| 71 | Morningside College (IA) | 54 |
| 72 | Bethany College (KS) | 54 |
| 73 | Wilmington College (OH) | 53 |
| 74 | Warner Pacific College (OR) | 53 |
| 75 | Lenoir-Rhyne University (NC) | 53 |
| 76 | Shorter College (GA) | 53 |
| 77 | Tabor College (KS) | 53 |
| 78 | Black Hills State University (SD)* | 53 |
| 79 | LeMoyne-Owen College (TN) | 52 |
| 80 | Patten University (CA) | 52 |
| 81 | Ohio Christian University (OH) | 52 |
| 82 | Dana College (NE) | 52 |
| 83 | Bethune-Cookman University (FL) | 51 |
| 84 | Bluffton University (OH) | 51 |
| 85 | Maine Maritime Academy (ME)* | 51 |
| 86 | Free Will Baptist Bible College (TN) | 51 |
| 87 | Southern Arkansas University (AR)* | 51 |
| 88 | Covenant College (GA) | 51 |
| 89 | Midland Lutheran College (NE) | 51 |
| 90 | Master's College and Seminary (CA) | 51 |
| 91 | Culver-Stockton College (MO) | 51 |
| 92 | St. Joseph's College (IN) | 50 |
| 93 | SUNY Maritime College (NY)* | 50 |
| 94 | East Texas Baptist University (TX) | 50 |
| 95 | College of Our Lady of the Elms (MA) | 50 |
| 96 | Coker College (SC) | 50 |
| 97 | North Carolina Wesleyan College (NC) | 50 |
| 98 | Davis and Elkins College (WV) | 50 |
| 99 | Vaughn College of Aeronautics and Technology (NY) | 49 |
| 100 | Adrian College (MI) | 49 |
| 101 | Clearwater Christian College (FL) | 49 |
| 102 | Glenville State College (WV)* | 49 |
| 103 | Pennsylvania State University-Penn State Dubois (PA)* | 49 |